Members: bedford67 >> Critiques Written

Register

Critiques: Critiques Written | Critiques Received | Comments
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  >

PhotoCritique [Translate]

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-09 9:00]

Hi Zeno,
Composition: 4 - Good composition of this protrait
POV: 4
DOF: 4
Sharpness: 4
Contrast: 3
Colours: 3

4+4+4+4+3+3=22 divide per 3 = 7,33 corresponding to a content smiley.

Don't be annoyed! This is a test of new notation.
I would wish that a charter of notation be installation on TN. For this purpose, I invite you to take note of my proposal on the forum during the discussion “A charter for TrekNature”. I would be happy that you deliver your opinion to it.

TFS, cordially,
Jean-Patrick

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-09 8:45]

Hi Steeve,
Composition: 4 - Very good composition
POV: 2 - A broader sight would make it possible not to cut the trees of the first-plan
DOF: 3
Sharpness: 4
Contrast: 3
Colours: 2

4+2+3+4+3+2=18 divide per 3 = 6 points
1 point more for the interesting note give you a total of 7 points corresponding to the content smiley.

You are the first on which I test my notation. I would wish that a charter of notation be installation on TN. For this purpose, I invite you to take note of my proposal on the forum during the discussion “A charter for TrekNature”. I would be happy that you deliver your opinion to it.

TFS, cordially,
Jean-Patrick

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-04 8:35]

Hello Manyee,
What beautiful colours! You made a very interesting photograph. I like much the different tone of blue from the veins of the rocks. The algae also have very contrasted colours.
TFS, cordially,
Jean-Patrick

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-04 2:52]

Bonjour Henry,
Cette photo est superbe même si elle a été fortement agrandie. Les détails sont très nets et les couleurs des martin-pêcheurs sont bien mises en valeur. Félicitations.
MPLP, cordialement,
Jean-Patrick

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-04 2:34]

Bonjour J Louis,
Superbe photo! Les détails du papillon et de la fleur sont très fins et l'ensemble de la photo est de grande qualité, bravo!
MPLP, cordialement,
Jean-Patrick

Poland
Title: Dancer
Dancer (63)
cafecrem Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1201 W: 60 N: 1392] (9248)

Great

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-04 2:27]

Hello Joanna,
Very nice shot! The composition is well seen, even if personally I cut the top of the photograph to eliminate the white sky. The colours and contrast are excellent.
TFS, cordially,
Jean-Patrick

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-04 2:21]

Hi Jaap,
Very nice shot! I like much the blue of the butterfly which is very quite enlightened on this photograph. The details are very sharp, put aside the top of the wing of the foreground, but that does not waste the quality of the unit.
TFS, cordially,
Jean-Patrick

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-04 2:08]

Bonjour Christian,
Je ne savais pas qu'il y avait de si beaux lys en montagne! Merci de me le faire découvrir aussi joliment. Les couleurs sont superbes et les détails très fins. J'aime bien l'arrière-plan très naturel. La note, comment toujours, est instructive et complète.
MPLP, cordialement,
Jean-Patrick

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-03 11:18]

Hi Cem,
You are right to specify that it is some time quite difficult to make the correct adjustments for a photograph when the subject is impatient to leave you ;-)
This known as, your photograph does not miss interest and I find that you made a success of an excellent shot there. The details and the colours are very well.
TFS, cordially,
Jean-Patrick

bedford67 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 108 W: 0 N: 164] (438) [2005-08-03 11:10]

Hello Jan,
I never saw such a mushroom! Thank you for sharing it with us because it is extremely nicely photographed. The details and colours are perfect.
Cordially,
Jean-Patrick